Guides
Humidor Humidity Too High or Too Low: How to Fix It
Humidor humidity counts as too high or too low relative to a target of about 70 per cent, so the first step is to confirm that the hygrometer is accurate. Excess moisture is reduced by removing sources of water and letting more air move through the box, while a dry reading is raised by adding a controlled moisture source and checking the seal. Smaller drifts of a point or two are normal and nothing to worry about.
First, check the reading
Before changing anything, ask whether the number can be trusted. Many hygrometers supplied with humidors are out by several points, so a "problem" may be a faulty gauge and not a faulty box. The salt test gives a reference: a sealed container with damp table salt settles near 75 per cent relative humidity at room temperature, and the gap between that and your gauge is its error. The method is set out in calibrating a hygrometer.
The target itself is a convention, not a law. The background to the 70 per cent figure, and why temperature belongs beside it, is covered in the 70/70 rule explained. Only act once you know the reading is real and has stayed off target for a sustained period, not for a single afternoon.
Humidity too high: causes and fixes
A humidor that reads well above target is not "extra safe". Persistent excess moisture invites mould and makes cigars swell, taste flat and resist lighting. The usual culprits and gentle responses are below.
| Symptom | Likely cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Reading well above target after setting up or reseasoning | Wood or humidifier holding too much water | Remove or let the humidifier dry out a little, and give the box time to settle before judging it |
| Reading creeps upward over days | Humidifier too large or too wet for the box volume | Use less liquid or a gentler solution, or switch to a smaller element |
| Cigars feel soft or spongy, hard to light | Cigars have taken up excess moisture | Dry them slowly in a lower-humidity setting, as described in reviving dry cigars |
| High reading in warm weather or a warm room | Warm, still, humid air | Move the humidor somewhere cooler and steadier; see cigars in hot, humid climates |
| Musty smell or fuzzy marks | Mould, usually after prolonged excess | Isolate affected cigars and follow mould identification and treatment |
Lowering the humidity should be gradual. Reduce the moisture source first, and only then consider brief, supervised airing with the lid slightly open. Leaving a box open for long periods overshoots quickly. A two-way pack that holds a fixed level can also act as a buffer, as explained in two-way humidity control packs.
Humidity too low: causes and fixes
Low humidity dries the leaf, which becomes brittle and burns hot and fast. The cause is nearly always that moisture is leaving faster than it is supplied.
| Symptom | Likely cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Reading low soon after a new humidor is filled | Bare or poorly seasoned wood drawing in water | Season properly before loading; see seasoning a new humidor |
| Reading slowly falls between top-ups | Humidifier dry, exhausted or undersized | Recharge it with distilled water or the maker's specified solution; see propylene glycol and other humidifiers |
| Reading drops every time the lid is opened | Frequent opening and a dry room, especially in winter | Open less often and for less time; allow the wood to recover |
| Reading never reaches target | Leaking seal | Check the lid fits evenly all round; a leaky box exhausts any humidifier |
| Cigars crackle and feel light | Cigars have lost moisture | Rehydrate gradually, never with direct water or steam; see reviving dry cigars |
Raise humidity in small steps. Adding a great deal of water at once tends to swing the reading past the target, replacing one problem with another.
Why humidity drifts
A humidor is a balance between cigars, the wood lining (traditionally Spanish cedar) and the humidifier, as described in how a humidor works. Several things shift that balance:
- Temperature. Relative humidity depends on temperature, so the same moisture reads higher when the room cools and lower when it warms.
- Volume and contents. A large cabinet needs more moisture than a small box, and adding or removing cigars changes how much the wood and leaf hold.
- Type of humidifier. Plain water in foam can push a small box high, while salt-based packs hold a set point.
- Opening. Each opening swaps humid interior air for room air.
- The seal. A poor fit lets moisture escape continuously.
Signs of too much moisture
Watch for a sticky or soft wrapper, swollen cigars, a sour or musty smell and fuzzy patches. Mould is soft and fluffy and may smear, while plume, a fine crystalline bloom on well-aged cigars, brushes off cleanly. If unsure, treat it as mould. Warm, damp conditions also suit the tobacco beetle, Lasioderma serricorne; tiny holes or fine dust are a warning sign, covered in the tobacco beetle. Do not smoke cigars with heavy or deep mould.
How long a humidor takes to stabilise
There is no fixed timetable. A box needs time for the wood, cigars and humidifier to reach a common level, and the time varies with the size of the box, the room and how far off target it started. Make one change at a time, then watch a calibrated gauge over several days before adjusting again. Repeated tinkering is the commonest reason a humidor never settles.
What not to do
- Do not flood the box or pour liquid onto the wood or cigars.
- Do not use water other than distilled water or the solution the humidifier maker specifies, and avoid scented additives.
- Do not mix humidity packs of different ratings in one box.
- Do not chase a gauge you have not checked.
- Do not assume more humidity is safer; see the myth that more humidity is safer.
Tobacco is harmful and addictive, and this guide is for adults. It is about storing cigars, not an invitation to smoke them.
Frequently asked questions
How do I lower the humidity in a humidor?
Confirm the hygrometer is accurate, then reduce the moisture source: use less liquid, a gentler solution or a smaller humidifier. Move the box somewhere cooler and allow a little more air exchange, but avoid leaving the lid open for long.
How do I raise the humidity in a humidor?
Check the gauge and the lid seal first. If both are sound, recharge the humidifier with distilled water or its specified solution, open the box less often and add moisture in small steps.
Why is my humidor humidity too high?
Common causes are an oversized or over-wet humidifier, a recently seasoned box, a warm or still location, or a gauge that reads high. Check the instrument before changing the setup.
Why is my humidor humidity too low?
Usually moisture is leaving faster than it is supplied: a dry or exhausted humidifier, unseasoned wood, a leaking seal, frequent opening or a dry room. A gauge reading low is also possible.
What humidity should a humidor be at?
About 70 per cent relative humidity is the long-standing guideline, paired with a moderate temperature. It is a convention, and small variations are normal; see the 70/70 rule explained.
How long does it take a humidor to stabilise?
It depends on the box, the room and how far it started from target. Allow several days between changes and judge by a calibrated hygrometer, not by a single reading.
Is more humidity safer for cigars?
No. Too much moisture risks mould, swelling and poor burning, just as too little risks brittleness. A stable, moderate level is the aim.
Reader questions
Questions & answers
No questions yet. Ask the first one.
