Book reviews
Smoke: A Global History of Smoking (Gilman and Zhou)
Smoke: A Global History of Smoking is an edited academic collection, edited by Sander L. Gilman and Zhou Xun and published by Reaktion Books in 2004. It brings together essays by different authors on how smoking developed in many regions and how societies have understood it.
An edited collection
Unlike a single-author narrative, this book assembles chapters by different contributors. The editors frame the volume, and each essay looks at a place, period or theme. That structure means the reader gets multiple viewpoints and styles in one volume.
The result is broader than any single scholar could cover, though the uneven quality and varying focus of a collection is something to expect.
Global perspective
The title signals the approach: smoking is treated as a worldwide phenomenon with regional histories, not a story told only from Europe or North America. This helps correct the common impression that the history runs in one line from the Americas to Europe and then outward.
Readers focused on cigars will find that cigars are one form among several. The value for them lies in context, such as how tobacco use took different shapes in different societies and how the same practice carried different meanings.
Themes of the essays
Collections like this typically address social meaning, gender, class, medicine, commerce and cultural representation. Consult the contents of the edition you hold to see exactly which topics are covered, since this guide cannot list each chapter reliably.
Pairing with other titles
It works well after a general survey such as Gately's cultural history, and as a complement to the interpretive approach of Cuban Counterpoint. Academic libraries commonly hold it, and chapters can often be read independently.
How to read an essay collection
Start with the editors' introduction, which usually explains the aims and links the chapters. Then choose the chapters that match your interest rather than reading in order. Each essay will have its own notes, and those references can lead to deeper reading on a region or theme.
Value for cigar enthusiasts
Even if you care only about cigars, the wider view corrects a narrow perspective. It shows that attitudes to smoking have always been contested and varied, and it places the cigar within a long human practice. That context improves how you read cigar marketing and nostalgia alike.
Why a collection helps
A single author must choose a thesis. An edited volume can hold several, which lets disagreements show. Readers see that experts do not always agree about causes, meanings or evidence, and that history is an argument as well as a story. That is a healthy corrective to neat one-line summaries.
Practical access
Because it is an academic press book, it is commonly found in university and larger public libraries. You may also be able to borrow it through interlibrary loan. If you only need one chapter, ask the library about chapter copies under its policy. Check the contents page of your edition to confirm which essays are included.
Where it leads next
The notes at the end of each chapter are the real gift of such a book. Follow them to monographs on regions, periods or themes that interest you. Combine them with the general narrative of Gately and you have the beginnings of a serious reading programme.
Questions the book raises
Reading the essays prompts useful questions. How did local customs shape the way a plant was used? Who controlled trade and who benefited? How did ideas about health, class and gender change what smoking meant? Writing your own answers, then testing them against other sources, is the best way to learn from a collection.
The book also invites caution about generalisation. Practices described in one place may not apply in another, and a claim about smoking in general may not hold for cigars in particular. Keep the scope of each essay in mind when you quote it, and always note the contributor's name rather than citing only the editors.
Frequently asked questions
Who edited the book?
Sander L. Gilman and Zhou Xun.
Is it written by one author?
No. It is a collection of essays by multiple contributors, framed by the editors.
Is it about cigars specifically?
No. It covers smoking broadly, so cigars appear as part of a wider history.
Reader questions
Questions & answers
No questions yet. Ask the first one.
