Guides
How to take cigar tasting notes
Cigar tasting notes are a written record of what you observed while smoking a particular cigar, covering appearance, aroma, flavor, strength, construction and your overall impression. Good notes make your preferences visible, help you compare cigars fairly over time and turn vague memories into usable information.
Decide what you will record
Before you start, choose a consistent set of categories so each entry can be compared with the last. A practical set includes the cigar name and size, the date, the setting, the appearance of the wrapper, the dry aroma, the cold draw, flavors in each third, strength, burn and draw, and a short overall summary.
Consistency matters more than detail. A simple template used every time is far more useful than an elaborate one used once. You can keep notes in a notebook, a spreadsheet or a notes app, as long as you can search and review them later.
Use plain, honest words
You do not need poetic language. Start with broad families such as woody, earthy, sweet, spicy, nutty, creamy, leathery, floral or fruity, and narrow them down when you can. If you taste something you cannot name, write down what it reminds you of, even if the description is personal, like a certain kind of bread or a place you remember.
Avoid copying descriptions from packaging or reviews. Reading another person's notes before smoking tends to bias you toward their flavors. Write your own impressions first and consult other sources afterward, if you wish, to see where you agree.
Separate observation from judgment
It helps to keep what you perceived apart from how much you liked it. A cigar can be intensely earthy and well made while still not matching your taste, and the reverse is also true. Write the description first, then add a line for personal enjoyment.
Record context honestly. Mood, tiredness, food eaten earlier, the drink beside you, weather and noise can all alter perception. If a cigar disappointed you on a day when you were rushed, a note about that circumstance will save you from dismissing it permanently.
Track the evolution
Cigars change as they burn. Divide your notes into thirds or at least into beginning, middle and end. Note when flavors appear or fade, when strength rises, when bitterness arrives, and whether the finish becomes longer or shorter. These shifts describe the cigar's structure and are often more revealing than any single flavor.
Also record physical performance: how the ash held, whether the burn line stayed even, whether relights were needed and whether the draw changed. Performance notes help distinguish a flavor you dislike from a construction problem.
Review your notes
The value of notes appears when you read them back. After several entries, look for patterns. Perhaps you consistently prefer cigars with a creamy texture, or you notice that you rate cigars higher in the morning. Those patterns can guide how you choose future cigars and how you interpret ratings from others.
A simple starter template
If you are unsure where to begin, try this order: name and size, date and setting, wrapper and dry aroma, cold draw, first third, second third, final third, strength on a simple low-to-high scale, burn and draw, and a closing sentence beginning with whether you would smoke it again and why.
Keep the first few entries short. Five or six lines are plenty, and the habit of writing every time will matter more than the quality of any single note. As your vocabulary grows, the entries will naturally become richer without extra effort.
Finally, store notes where you will actually look at them. A pile of loose scraps rarely gets reviewed, while a single document or notebook invites you to flip back and compare.
Frequently asked questions
How many words should a note contain?
A few lines per stage are usually enough. What matters is that you can compare entries, so use the same structure each time.
Should I take notes during or after smoking?
Brief jottings at the end of each third work well, followed by a short summary right after finishing. Waiting until the next day risks losing details.
Is it a problem if my descriptions differ from others?
No. Perception varies between people, and your notes are for your own reference. Differences are normal and often interesting.
Reader questions
Questions & answers
No questions yet. Ask the first one.
