• Secure payment

Guides

How cigar ratings work

By Vitola Room Editorial TeamVitola Room Editorial · 3 min read
How cigar ratings work

Cigar ratings are numerical or descriptive scores that reviewers assign to cigars to summarize their quality in a compact, comparable form. Understanding how those scores are produced, and where they are limited, helps you use them as one input among many rather than as a final answer.

What a rating is

A rating is a reviewer's condensed judgment of a specific cigar at a specific moment. It may be a score on a hundred-point scale, a smaller numeric scale, stars or a simple category such as recommended. Different publications and reviewers use different systems, and there is no single global standard, so a number only has meaning within the system that produced it.

Because each system defines its own scale, a score from one source cannot be directly compared with a score from another. A figure that is considered modest in one scheme might be excellent in a second. Always look for how the scale is explained.

How scores are typically built

Most rating methods break the experience into components such as appearance, construction, flavor, balance and finish, then combine them either by adding points or by an overall judgment. Some use blind tasting to reduce bias, while others are open. The weight given to each category varies, and it is not always disclosed.

Reviewers are human, and their results depend on palate, experience and circumstances. Reputable reviews usually describe the cigar tasted, the size and the conditions, which helps you interpret the score.

Limits and biases

Several issues deserve caution. Cigars vary from one individual to another, so a score reflects the sample that was smoked and not every cigar of that blend. Age and storage affect results, and a cigar reviewed fresh may behave differently later. Scores can also cluster at the high end of the scale, which makes it harder to separate excellent from merely good.

Commercial relationships can create pressure as well. When evaluating a source, look for clear descriptions of how cigars are obtained and tasted, and prefer reviewers who explain their approach and are open about limitations.

Using ratings sensibly

Treat ratings as a starting point for exploration. Use them to identify cigars worth trying, then read the descriptive text, which tells you more about flavor and style than a number can. Compare several sources rather than relying on one, and pay particular attention to the descriptions of strength and profile, since your own preferences may differ from the reviewer's.

Most importantly, test ratings against your own palate. If you keep notes, you can see whether your scores usually agree with a given reviewer. Once you know whose taste aligns with yours, their reviews become much more useful.

Rate your own

Making your own ratings is the best way to understand the system. Choose a scale, define what each level means and use it consistently. The exercise of deciding between a good and a very good cigar teaches you what you value, and it highlights how subjective the exercise is.

Reading a review critically

When you read a review, ask a few questions. Who wrote it, and how do they describe their method? Was the cigar tasted blind? How many cigars were sampled? Does the text explain the score, or is the number all that appears? Is the cigar described in terms of its flavor and strength, or only praised in general terms?

A review that answers these questions is generally more trustworthy and more useful than one that does not. Even then, treat it as one voice. Your own palate, mood and expectations remain the final judge of whether a cigar is right for you.

Frequently asked questions

Can I compare a score from one magazine with another?

Not directly. Each system has its own scale and criteria, so scores are only comparable within the same system.

Do high ratings guarantee I will enjoy a cigar?

No. Ratings reflect the reviewer's taste and a particular sample, so your own experience may differ.

Are blind reviews more reliable?

They reduce the influence of brand and expectation, but they still depend on the reviewer's palate and the specific cigar tasted.

Reader questions

Questions & answers

No questions yet. Ask the first one.

All articles