Guides
Fuels to avoid when lighting a cigar
The flame used to light a cigar can leave a taste behind. Some fuels and flame sources add unpleasant flavours or smells to the tobacco, so knowing which ones to avoid is part of lighting a cigar properly.
Why the flame source matters
A cigar absorbs aromas easily. The foot is exposed to the flame for several moments during toasting and lighting, and anything that burns dirty can deposit its smell on the tobacco. Once those aromas settle into the first puffs, they can colour the early part of the smoke.
Choosing a clean-burning source is therefore one of the simplest ways to protect the flavour of a good cigar.
Petroleum-based fuels
Lighters that burn liquid fuels such as naphtha, commonly used in some classic flip-top lighters, are widely considered poor choices for cigars. Their flame can give off a noticeable chemical smell, and that smell can transfer to the foot.
If you own a lighter of this type, many smokers prefer to keep it for other uses and light cigars with a butane lighter, a wooden match or a cedar spill.
Candles and paraffin wax
Candles produce a smoky, sooty flame and can leave a waxy smell. The flame also tends to flicker, which makes it harder to light a cigar evenly. For these reasons, candles are generally best avoided.
If a candle is the only flame available, it is better than nothing, but the wick and wax can affect flavour.
Paper, cardboard and ordinary matches
Lighting a cigar from a piece of paper or cardboard may seem convenient, but burning paper creates smoke and a distinct smell that can transfer to the tobacco. Ordinary short matches are also a risk, since the head burns with a sulphurous smell and the short stem puts your fingers close to the flame.
Long cigar matches or cedar spills solve both problems, as explained in our article on those tools.
Stoves, gas rings and open fires
It can be tempting to light a cigar from a kitchen burner or a campfire, and in an emergency that may work. However, gas rings may burn with a chemical odour, and open fires can carry smoke from wood or other materials. Both can alter the flavour of the first puffs.
If you must use one, hold the foot well away from the main flame and take care that nothing burnt contacts the tobacco.
Better options
- Butane lighters, which burn cleanly when properly maintained.
- Long wooden matches, after the head has burned off.
- Cedar spills, which add a mild, pleasant aroma.
Whichever you choose, keep the flame at a distance from the tobacco and avoid scorching the foot.
Safety
Beyond flavour, safety is a concern. Never refill a lighter with a fuel it was not designed for, and never use fuels like lamp oil or lighter fluid intended for charcoal as a cigar flame. Follow the manufacturer's instructions and keep lighters away from heat.
Taste and habit
Individual sensitivity to fuel aromas varies. Some smokers claim to notice even a faint trace of lighter fuel, while others are less bothered. If you are unsure, try an experiment: light two similar cigars in different ways, with butane and with a cedar spill, and compare the first few puffs. Many people find the difference noticeable. The point is not to follow a rigid rule but to be aware of the effect and choose accordingly. A clean flame costs nothing extra and tends to let the character of the cigar speak for itself.
If you are ever unsure whether a flame source is clean, a simple test is to smell it as it burns. Any sharp, chemical or sooty odour is a warning that it may transfer to the cigar. A neutral or faintly sweet smell is a better sign.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use a flip-top fluid lighter for cigars?
Many smokers avoid lighters that burn liquid fuels such as naphtha because the flame can leave a chemical smell on the tobacco. Butane or wood are generally preferred.
Is it bad to light a cigar from a candle?
A candle can leave a waxy, smoky taste and gives an unsteady flame. It is better to use a cleaner source.
Why avoid ordinary matches?
The head produces a sulphurous smell and the short stem is awkward to use. Long cigar matches or cedar spills are better.
Reader questions
Questions & answers
No questions yet. Ask the first one.
