Guides
Vertical tastings: one cigar across years
A vertical tasting compares the same cigar from different production years, or from the same box smoked at different stages of aging, in order to observe how time changes it. Borrowed from the language of wine tasting, the format is one of the most instructive ways to understand what aging does to tobacco and what a blend is made of.
The idea behind a vertical
Holding the cigar constant removes most variables and leaves time as the main difference. If the blend, size and brand are the same, the changes you perceive can reasonably be attributed to age, harvest differences or storage. That makes verticals a clean experiment in a field where clean experiments are rare.
The term borrows from wine, where a vertical means several vintages of one wine. In cigars the concept is similar, though the details differ, because production years are not always clearly marked and blends can change quietly over time.
Sourcing the cigars
The hardest part of a vertical is assembling comparable cigars. Some boxes carry a date code or a stamp that indicates when they were packed, and collectors often rely on that. Not every producer marks boxes consistently, and codes vary between brands, so verify what a code means for the specific cigar before drawing conclusions.
Another approach is to buy several of the same cigar and age some of them yourself, then compare them over the years. This takes patience but gives you complete knowledge of the storage history, which is a real advantage. If you are tasting cigars acquired from other people, remember that unknown storage can matter as much as age.
Running the session
Keep the setup consistent: same time of day, same drink, same palate cleanser, and a helper to blind the order if possible. Taste from youngest to oldest or the reverse, but be consistent and record which you chose. Allow breaks, since multiple cigars in one sitting tire the palate. Many people spread a vertical across several days or sessions.
Take notes using the same categories for each cigar. Pay particular attention to strength, harshness or rawness, sweetness, texture and the length of the finish. Those are the areas where age is most often discussed.
What you may notice
Tasters often report that younger cigars can feel sharper or more tightly wound, while older ones can seem smoother and more integrated. This is a common description rather than a rule. Some cigars are most enjoyable young, and some lose vitality with time, especially if poorly stored. Whether a given cigar improves is a question to be answered by your own palate.
Be careful not to assume that older automatically means better. Expectation is strong in verticals, so a blind format is particularly valuable here.
Drawing conclusions
After the session, compare your impressions with the identities. Which year did you prefer? Did the differences you noted match your expectations? Write down the result and the conditions. With several verticals under your belt, you can decide how long you like to keep your cigars and which blends reward patience for your taste.
Keeping good records
A vertical is only as useful as its documentation. Record where each cigar came from, the date code or the purchase date if known, how it was stored, and its apparent condition before lighting. Photograph the box or band if possible. When you return to your notes years later, these details will be the difference between a puzzle and a lesson.
Also note anything unusual about the individual cigar. Because each stick may vary, a single odd sample should not be treated as proof of a trend, and repeating the tasting with a second cigar from each year improves your confidence.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know a cigar's production year?
Some boxes carry a date code, but systems differ between producers. Check what a code means for the specific brand, and treat undocumented claims cautiously.
Do cigars always improve with age?
No. Some are enjoyable young, and storage affects the outcome strongly. Aging is a matter of preference and conditions.
Can I run a vertical at home?
Yes. Buy several of the same cigar, age a portion and compare them over time, keeping careful storage records.
Reader questions
Questions & answers
No questions yet. Ask the first one.
