Book reviews
The Ultimate Cigar Book by Richard Carleton Hacker
The Ultimate Cigar Book by Richard Carleton Hacker is a general illustrated guide to cigars first published in 1993 and revised in later editions. It covers the history of the cigar, how cigars are made, brand and size information, and practical advice on enjoying them.
A general guide in the boom-era tradition
Like other popular guides of the 1990s, this book tries to give a reader everything in one place. It aims at the interested newcomer and the growing community of enthusiasts, and it blends background with practical tips.
Because there have been several editions, the contents differ between printings. When choosing a copy, look at the edition and date, as this affects how current the brand and market information is.
What readers can expect
Expect sections on the history of tobacco and cigars, the process from plant to finished product, and the vocabulary of shapes and sizes. Practical chapters typically cover storage, cutting, lighting and etiquette.
The book is organised for browsing, so you can dip into a section about a topic without reading cover to cover.
Reading with a critical eye
General guides simplify. Some statements about flavour, strength or brand character are opinion and varied between authors even then. Compare with other books on the shelf, such as Davidoff's guide and Bati's Cigar Companion, to see where authors agree.
For storage, today's reader should cross-check with How to store Habanos, since practices evolve.
Role on a collector's shelf
Guides like this are collected both for their content and as artefacts of cigar publishing. A small collection of them shows how presentation and advice changed over time. See Collecting cigar literature for more on building such a shelf.
Handbook features
Handbook-style books usually include glossaries, lists and summary tables that help you find a fact quickly. When using such features, remember that a list reflects the edition's date. Treat lists of brands or sizes as a snapshot and confirm against a current source before relying on them.
Comparing guides
A useful exercise is to take one topic, such as how to light a cigar, and read how three different guides treat it. Where they agree, you can be fairly confident. Where they disagree, you have found a matter of taste or changing practice, and you can try both approaches yourself.
Reading for the practical sections
If you want to use the book, start with the practical chapters. Storage, cutting and lighting are areas where basic principles are stable, and a general guide can explain them clearly. Try the methods and adjust to your own preference rather than treating any single recommendation as a rule.
Reading for the background
The background chapters on history and manufacture give a quick orientation. They are not a substitute for specialised works, but they give you the outline to which you can attach details from other books. When a topic grabs your interest, follow it into a more focused source such as Smoke or Tobacco on the Periphery.
What to check
As with any general guide, verify names, dimensions and availability statements against a current official source. A reader who checks will find the book more useful, because it stops being a source of unquestioned facts and becomes a starting point for investigation, which is exactly how a good general book should be used.
Using it as part of a shelf
No single general guide can answer every question. Treat this one as a hub: use it for orientation, then branch out. A good pattern, and one that works for every guide on a shelf, is to read the overview of a topic, note what remains unclear, and consult a specialised source for each question. Over time your notes will show which books you reach for and why, which is a useful guide to what your own shelf still lacks. It also keeps you honest about which titles you actually use.
If you are building that shelf, Collecting cigar literature suggests a balanced mix of categories.
Frequently asked questions
Who wrote it?
Richard Carleton Hacker, a writer on cigars and related subjects.
Are there several editions?
Yes, later editions were revised, so details vary and it is worth checking the edition and date of any copy.
Is it a reference or a narrative?
It is a general illustrated guide that mixes background with practical advice, closer to a handbook than a scholarly history.
Reader questions
Questions & answers
No questions yet. Ask the first one.
